I have to admit I was really excited when I first found out about this compilation. After X-men: Misfits and Wolverine: Prodigal Son, I was very interested to see what the manga format would do for Batman. While not exactly what I expected, I can't say I was disappointed either. The juxtaposition between Batman's costume and the oni of Japanese legend was a very clever connection to make and Natsume uses the idea well. The whole concept of masks and "face stealing" is also creepily cool...although almost too graphic for my personal tastes. The story moves a bit fast in some places, which might cause some minor confusion with readers, but overall it's pretty seamless, and the plot itself, while a bit predictable here and there, was still intriguing to watch unfold.
As for the artwork, I truly enjoyed it - especially the brush-like quality of the dream/illusion/legend sequences and the awesome battle sequences. The lines were smooth and clean throughout and the characters were nicely executed. My only complaint, and it's a very minor one, is that Bruce Wayne looked a bit too old...but that's just my personal tastes.
Overall, I'd have to say that this stand-alone graphic novel would make an excellent addition to any Young Adult collection. It's great for introducing fans of manga to an American graphic novel icon, but also for the opposite reason - introducing Batman fans to the world of manga. Plus, because it's a one-shot comic, you don't have to worry about keeping up with a bunch of different volumes. You just can't really lose with this one.
